Notched sound and masking: what they are, and what the research says
Two kinds of sound come up again and again in tinnitus apps: masking and notched sound. They work in opposite ways: masking covers the ringing, and notched sound leaves a quiet gap where the ringing sits.
Masking: sound that covers the ringing
Masking means playing a steady sound, such as rain, a fan, the sea or soft noise, so the ringing is covered or blends in. It is the most common use of tinnitus apps, mostly at night. In the app store reviews we read while planning Earlull, people often said the sound “overlaps the ringing” and helps them sleep.
What it can do: make tinnitus less noticeable while the sound plays, and make a quiet room feel less empty. What it cannot do: change the tinnitus itself. When the sound stops, the ringing is still there. A 2018 Cochrane review of sound therapy found no evidence that it works better than other options such as education or waiting (Sereda and colleagues). The evidence was of low quality, so the honest summary is “not proven either way”, and many people find it helps them get through the night.
If you use masking, keep it as quiet as still feels comfortable. There is no need for it to drown the ringing out.
Notched sound: a gap at your pitch
Notched sound starts from music or noise and cuts out a band of pitches around your tinnitus frequency, usually about one octave wide. The idea, from brain research, is that leaving that band quiet may help calm the overactive part of the hearing system linked to the ringing. Because the gap has to sit on your tone, you need to know your tinnitus frequency first.
What the research says about notched sound
It is mixed.
- The first study was promising but small. In 2010, eight people listened to notched music, with the gap at their own tinnitus pitch, for a year, and rated their tinnitus as significantly quieter. A comparison group of eight heard music with the gap in the wrong place (Okamoto and colleagues, PNAS).
- A larger trial found no clear benefit on the main measures. In 2016, 100 people with tonal tinnitus listened for two hours a day for three months. On the main measures of how much tinnitus bothered them, “no effect was found”. Loudness ratings were lower than in the comparison group at follow-up (Stein and colleagues, BMC Neurology).
- A 2024 review of seven trials found no significant effect on how much tinnitus affected people’s lives (Tavanai and colleagues).
So notched sound is not a proven therapy. Some people like listening to it, and in app reviews some say it helped them. If you try it, keep the volume low and see how you feel after a few weeks.
Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), a talking therapy, has been studied more widely for the distress tinnitus causes: a 2020 Cochrane review covered 28 studies (Fuller and colleagues). Sound and CBT can go together.
How Earlull uses both
Earlull is built around sound you can live with every night: masking sounds that keep playing with the screen off, and notched versions tuned to the tone you find with What’s My Tone?. On this site you can hear a 10-minute demo of notched sound right after you find your tone, and switch the notch off and on to hear the difference. No sound can promise to make tinnitus go away. What it can give you is something softer to listen to while you fall asleep.
Not medical advice. Earlull plays and matches sounds. It is not a medical device and it does not diagnose, treat or cure tinnitus or any other condition. If your tinnitus is new, in one ear only, pulsing, or comes with hearing loss or dizziness, see a doctor.
Sources
- Okamoto H et al. Listening to tailor-made notched music reduces tinnitus loudness and tinnitus-related auditory cortex activity. PNAS, 2010
- Stein A et al. Clinical trial on tonal tinnitus with tailor-made notched music training. BMC Neurology, 2016
- Tavanai E et al. Efficacy of tailor-made notched music training (TMNMT) in the treatment of tinnitus: a systematic review and meta-analysis. European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology, 2024
- Sereda M et al. Sound therapy (using amplification devices and/or sound generators) for tinnitus. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2018
- Fuller T et al. Cognitive behavioural therapy for tinnitus. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2020